Marine Veteran discharged over Bible verse row may appear before military’s highest court

A Marine veteran who was discharged over ignoring an order to take down a Bible verse taped to her computer may have her case heard by the military’s highest court. Former Lance Cpl. Monifa Sterling received a bad-conduct discharge and was reduced in rank to an E-1 private after refusing an order from her supervisor while assigned to Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, in 2013. “No weapon formed against me shall prosper,” she had taped to the side of her computer in triplicate, Military Times reported Wednesday. When a staff sergeant told her to take down the variation on Isaiah 57:14, she refused and was ultimately discharged. Her violation of a lawful order, along with other low-level offenses, led to the decision, the newspaper reported. The Bible verse “could be interpreted as combative … [and] could easily be seen as contrary to good order and discipline,” the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Appeals said in February. Private Sterling, a native of New York, lost her appeal but the case has been taken up by the nonprofit organization the Liberty Institute. “To me, this is analogous to: What if a Marine wants to get a tattoo of a cross on their shoulder or on their back. Is the Marine Corps going to tell them that is religious, and you can’t do it?” said Michael Berry, the Liberty Institute attorney overseeing the veteran’s appeal, Military Times reported. Private Sterling’s upcoming appeal will hinge on her legal team’s presentation of religious rights protected under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The 1993 law says that the government must provide a good reason to restrict religious activities, the newspaper reported. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces may hear the veteran’s case sometime later this year, the newspaper reported.

In recent months we’ve seen a LOT of cases in the military, where clearly those of faith (including Chaplains) have come under fire for practicing their faith. And, we’ve come to the defense of these servicemembers, and their Chaplains. However, in this case, it would appear that this junior enlisted Marine was simply insubordinate. And, she apparently has a history of poor conduct. So, my initial gut reaction is that she was in the wrong. If you have a problem with a directive, there IS a process through which to appeal a directive. In this case, she simply chose to ignore the directive altogether. And, you cannot have that in any military command. So, while we normally, passionately support those in our armed services (especially of Christian faith, who seem to be under the most fire) for the right to practice their faith without reprisal from an ever-increasing politically correct military brass…in this case, at least from what we’re hearing…this isn’t about religious freedom. It’s about military discipline.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s